Comparison between Private Ltd and LLP
Private limited company registration is a popular option to start a business in India by start-ups and businesses with higher growth aspirations. Private limited company is incorporated under the Companies Act of 2013, and governed by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA).
Limited liability partnership is a business structure that combines the flexibility of a partnership with the limited liability protection of a company. It’s designed for professionals and businesses where partners seek to limit their personal liability while retaining management flexibility.
Difference between private ltd company and limited liability partnership(LLP)
| Feature | PRIVATE LIMITED COMPANY (LTD) | LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP (LLP) |
| legal status | Separate legal entity | Separate legal entity |
| liability | Limited to the amount unpaid on shares | Limited to the amount invested in the LIMITED LIBALITY PARTNERSHIP |
| Ownership | Owned by shareholders who hold shares | Owned by partners who share profits and responsibilities |
| Management Structure | Managed by directors, who may or may not be shareholders | Managed by partners, who can be individuals or entities |
| Profit Distribution | Dividends paid to shareholders | Distributed according to the partnership agreement |
| Taxation | Subject to corporate tax; dividends taxed at shareholder level | Generally taxed as a partnership (profits taxed at individual partner’s rates) |
| Regulatory Requirements | Must file annual returns, financial statements, and comply with company law | Must file annual returns and financial statements, but fewer corporate formalities |
| Transferability of Shares/Interest | Shares can be transferred, but often with restrictions | Partners’ interests can be transferred subject to agreement |
| Public Disclosure | Required to disclose financial statements and other company details | Required to disclose financial statements and some details about the partners |
| Formation Complexity | Requires registration with company registry, drafting of articles of association | Requires registration with partnership registry, drafting of a partnership agreement |
| Audit Requirements | May require annual audit depending on size and jurisdiction | Audit requirements vary; often no mandatory audit for smaller LIMITED LIBALITY PARTNERSHIPs |
| Flexibility in Management | Less flexible; roles and responsibilities defined by company law and articles | Highly flexible; roles and responsibilities can be tailored in the partnership agreement |
| Ownership and Control | Shareholders own the company, directors manage it | Partners own and manage the limited liability partnership, with control often shared among them |
| Ideal For | Companies looking for formal structure, potential for raising capital | Professional firms, businesses seeking flexible management, and partners wanting limited liability |
Advantages of Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)
Limited Liability
Partners have limited liability, meaning they are not personally responsible for the limited liability partnership’s debts beyond their investment in the business.
Flexibility in Management
Partners can define management roles, responsibilities, and profit distribution through a partnership agreement, allowing for a flexible operational structure.
Tax Efficiency
Limited liability partnerships are generally taxed as partnerships, meaning profits are taxed at the partners’ individual tax rates, which can be advantageous for tax planning. Unlike companies, LLPs do not pay Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT). LLPs can deduct various expenses related to their business operations before calculating taxable income.
No Corporate Tax
Limited liability partnerships avoid corporate taxation, as profits are passed through to the partners and taxed only once at the individual level.
Ease of Formation
Generally easier and less costly to set up compared to a private limited company, with fewer formalities.
Less Regulation
Limited liability partnerships often face fewer regulatory requirements and compliance burdens compared to private limited companies.
Disadvantages of a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)
Public Disclosure
Limited liability partnership are required to file annual financial statements and details about the partners with regulatory authorities. This information is often publicly accessible, which may not be desirable for all businesses.
Varied Liability Protection
While partners are generally protected from personal liability for the limited liability partnership’s debts, they can still be personally liable for their own negligence or misconduct. This limited liability does not extend to actions taken by other partners.
Limited Appeal for Investors
Limited liability partnership may be less attractive to external investors compared to private limited companies, as they cannot issue shares to raise capital and may lack the formal structure that some investors prefer.
Potential for Disputes
The flexibility in management and profit-sharing arrangements can lead to conflicts among partners, especially if the partnership agreement is not well-defined or is ambiguous.
Regulatory Requirements
Although limited liability partnership face fewer regulatory requirements than private limited companies, they are still required to comply with certain regulations, including filing annual returns and maintaining proper accounting records.
Perception Issues
In some sectors, limited liability partnership might be perceived as less formal or professional compared to private limited companies, which could impact client and partner relationships.
Transfer of Ownership
Transferring ownership interests can be more complicated than selling shares in a private limited company. Partners typically need to agree on the terms of any transfer, which can be restrictive and lead to potential disputes.
Limited Expansion Opportunities
Limited liability partnership may face challenges in expanding or restructuring compared to private limited companies, particularly if they require significant external investment or wish to go public.
Less Formal Structure
The flexible management structure of a limited liability partnership can lead to a lack of clarity or organization, which might be problematic for businesses that require a more defined hierarchy or formal governance.
Conversion process of Private Limited Company to limited liability partnership (LLP)
Converting a Private Limited Company (Ltd) into a Limited Liability Partnership LLP involves a specific legal process. All limited liability partnership can convert to a private limited company provided they meet the conditions set by the Companies Act, 2013 and the limited liability partnership Act, 2008. Conversion can provide access to equity financing, enhance credibility, and enable the company to raise capital by issuing shares. Private limited company has its own advantages like Limited Liability, ease of raising capital, tax advantages, Access funding etc. However, the process involves meticulous compliance with legal requirements and thorough documentation.
Conclusion
There is a huge difference between private limited company and limited liability partnership . there are many advantages and disadvantages are included between private ltd company and limited liability partnership. LLPs are well-suited for professionals and small to medium-sized businesses seeking the flexibility of a partnership while enjoying limited liability protection. Each partner in an LLP has limited personal liability for the debts and obligations of the business, which protects personal assets from business-related liabilities.
Private Limited Companies are ideal for businesses seeking limited liability protection and a formal structure with flexible management options. Shareholders’ liability is limited to the amount unpaid on their shares, protecting their personal assets from business debts and liabilities.
Company Suggestion has the best team of consultancy. Our consultants are not just advisors but partners invested in your long-term success. We provide actionable insights and practical recommendations, empowering you to make informed decisions. Transparency, integrity, and continuous improvement are the cornerstones of our practice.
